Free shipping over $45Small batch, Gulf Coast inspiredNo ghost pepper. Not now, not everEvery bottle its own journeyGood mood. Bold flavor.

Monroe County, the Lower Keys

Big Pine Key, Florida: lobster tails in Key deer country

The Lower Keys island with one traffic light, the world's smallest deer and a reef six miles offshore. Most of what lands on the grill here is spiny lobster.

A shaker of RiverKingz All Purpose Rub on a camp table at a beach campsite at sunset

Key deer country

Big Pine Key sits in the Lower Keys, the run of islands between the Seven Mile Bridge and Stock Island that the Monroe County tourism council sells on calm, seclusion and wildlife in the open. It is a small place, small enough that the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service gives driving directions by the only traffic light on the island.

That light marks the Nature Center of the National Key Deer Refuge, set up in 1957. Key deer are the smallest subspecies of white tailed deer and live nowhere but the lower Florida Keys. Poaching and lost habitat cut them to a few dozen animals by the 1950s. With the refuge, and endangered listing in 1967, the herd recovered, and the service estimates about three quarters of it now lives on Big Pine and neighboring No Name Key.

The refuge asks two things of visitors: do not feed the deer, and drive slowly from Big Pine west to Lower Sugarloaf Key, especially at night when deer move most. The rut starts in September and October, and spotted fawns show up from late spring through summer.

On the water side, the island faces Looe Key Reef, about six miles south, which the tourism council counts among the most vibrant reefs in the Keys. On land, Lower Keys menus run to freshly caught spiny lobster and conch fritters.

Bringing lobster home the legal way

If you plan to catch your own lobster, know that the FWC rules are strict. You must carry a measuring device, and the carapace has to be longer than 3 inches, measured before the lobster leaves the water. Spears, hooks or anything that can puncture the shell are banned, recreational traps are banned, and egg bearing females go back.

Lobsters must reach land whole, because separating tail from body is prohibited in state waters. The regular season runs August 6 to March 31 with a bag of six per person. The two day sport season in late July keeps the same six lobster limit in Monroe County and adds a ban on night diving.

What is in season

A year on Big Pine Key

Lobster and stone crab dates are from the FWC and deer notes are from the refuge. Fish timing comes from the Monroe County tourism council's fishing calendar, which shows good fishing months, not legal harvest dates.

What is in season in Big Pine Key, by month
WhatWhenMonths
Key deer fawning season, and big tarpon back in the channelsIn season nowMay and June
Underwater Music Festival at Looe KeyIn season nowJuly
Lobster sport seasonIn season nowLast Wednesday and Thursday of July Official dates for Lobster sport season (opens in a new tab)
Regular spiny lobster seasonIn season nowAugust 6 to March 31 Official dates for Regular spiny lobster season (opens in a new tab)
Key deer rut beginsIn season nowSeptember and October
Stone crab clawsIn season nowOctober 15 to May 1 Official dates for Stone crab claws (opens in a new tab)
Cobia at their bestIn season nowNovember to March

Festivals and events

Big Pine and Lower Keys dates

Checked in October 2026. The music festival had not posted 2027 dates. Dates update every month: confirmed means the organizers posted it, expected means it follows the usual pattern.

The next twelve months in Big Pine Key

  1. Oct2026Nothing on the calendar
  2. NovNothing on the calendar
  3. DecNothing on the calendar
  4. Jan2027Nothing on the calendar
  5. FebNothing on the calendar
  6. MarNothing on the calendar
  7. AprNothing on the calendar
  8. MayNothing on the calendar
  9. JunNothing on the calendar
  10. Jul9 July: Lower Keys Underwater Music Festival, expected28 July: Spiny lobster sport season, confirmed
  11. AugNothing on the calendar
  12. SepNothing on the calendar

From the lineup

What we would pack for a Big Pine rental

Lobster, whatever the guide brings back, and a campsite grill.

RiverKingz All Purpose Rub

Mild, 4 oz, $9

Garlic led and barely hot, with low salt. Melt it into butter for lobster tails so the sweet meat still leads.

Grand Isle Hook Set Sauce

Some Heat, 8 fl oz, $12

Louisiana style, red jalapeño and roasted red pepper with a lime finish. Good on lobster, fried fish and morning eggs.

Beautiful Sunset

Mild, 3.5 oz, $9

Orange peel and ancho with a little sweetness. A mild rub for grilled shrimp or snapper at the end of a long boat day.

Cook it at home

Grilled spiny lobster tails with garlic butter

The tail holds most of the meat on a spiny lobster. Split it, baste it and keep the heat moderate so the meat stays tender.

What you need

  • 4 spiny lobster tails, thawed if frozen
  • 6 tbsp butter
  • 2 tsp RiverKingz All Purpose Rub
  • 1 lime, halved
  • Grand Isle Hook Set Sauce

How it goes

  1. Heat the grill to medium. Melt the butter with the RiverKingz and a squeeze of lime.
  2. With kitchen shears, cut down the center of the top shell to the tail fan, then split the meat lengthwise with a knife without cutting through the bottom shell.
  3. Open the tails like a book and brush the meat with the seasoned butter.
  4. Grill meat side down for 3 to 4 minutes, then turn shell side down, baste again and cook 4 to 5 minutes more, until the meat is opaque white all the way through.
  5. Serve with the rest of the butter, lime and Hook Set Sauce at the table.
Worth knowing. Pull the tails the moment the center turns from glassy to white. A minute too long and lobster goes rubbery.

Another one from our kitchen: Grand Isle Shrimp and White Rice

Questions

Questions about Big Pine Key

Where can you see Key deer?

On Big Pine Key and No Name Key, where the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service estimates about 75 percent of them live. Start at the National Key Deer Refuge Nature Center on Big Pine.

Can you feed the Key deer?

No. The refuge asks visitors not to feed them, because handouts teach deer to approach people and cars.

How far is Looe Key Reef from Big Pine Key?

About six miles south. You need a boat, and charters run from Big Pine, Ramrod and Summerland Keys.

When is lobster season in the Lower Keys?

The regular season is August 6 to March 31. The two day sport season is the last consecutive Wednesday and Thursday of July, which is July 28 and 29 in 2027.

Do you ship to Big Pine Key?

Yes. We ship anywhere in the U.S. Orders go out within two business days, and shipping is free over $45.

Run a shop, market or kitchen in Big Pine Key? Carry JollyGringo'z by the case. Tell us about the shop and the price sheet, the case packs and a sample bottle come straight back.

Get the price sheet

Keep going

More Florida towns near Big Pine Key

All 47 Florida town guides

Ships anywhere in the U.S.

Cook like Big Pine Key, wherever you are

Ten small batch rubs and sauces, low on salt so you can season heavy. Any four, 15% off, and free shipping over $45.

We ship here, free over $45. Want it on your shelf? Wholesale. A tasting near you? Contact us

The lineupFree shipping over $45Shop the lineup

Listed by weight, most first.